PDA

View Full Version : LG Libero - Removing the 4C differential in heat mode when using the wired remotes



back2space
19-03-2013, 01:57 AM
Just sent this to LG technical, what do you guys think. Do I have a case to complain?

Good Morning Ken,

You may remember that I bought wired remotes for my LG wall mounts at home to control the on/off times of the systems rather than using a basic timer plug setup as you said the controller had a temp sensor to better control temperature. All my indoor units are the new style Libero units and work well apart from the fact that in heating there is a 4C differential before set point reaches off. So 22C the return air sensor has to sense 26C before it will cycle off.

This in theory would work fine with wall mounts where the return air sensor is at ceiling level. In my house however we was finding that control was very poor as a set point of 22C meant 26C at ceiling level which was usually about 24C at floor level so very warm. The unit would then not reach thermostat on until the temp at ceiling level would then drop below the set point by 1C - this took ages to do as heat rises at ceiling level whilst the occupied area of the room cooled quickly.

So part of the desicion to buy the wall wired remotes is that they have sensor in that can be used so room temp is measured at approx light switch level... once this setting was activated on the remote controller I would have thought the 4C differential would not be used so that the differential would be 1C over the set point, this would then work very well. The convertable units have a switch to deactivate high ceiling level (when used at floor level) which basically cancels the differential in heating. With a set point of 22C thermostat off would be reached at 23C. However this isnt how it has worked out, if using the remote control sensor the system still tries to achieve 4C differential so these expensive controllers are nothing more than a glorified timer plug that I could have picked up very cheap! There are various options to use just the unit sensor, the remote sensor or to use an average of them both but in heating all this does is use the lower reading value and not by adding them both together so the lower reading value will always be on the controller.

When I spoke with the helping they said I will have to experiment with the set points but I said well whatever set point I choose for example I could choose 20C the room will still reach 24C before it shuts off but then the room needs to drop below 20C to 19C before thermostat on is reached. This results in large fluctuation in temperatures. The system then wastes a lot of energy running when it doesnt need to. I remember when I spoke with you that you thought there was a setting to remove the differential however there is not.

I have remained very loyal to LG and when I moved into my new house I spent a lot of money on completly new units to remove the problems I was having with the previous units. I then spent near to £400 on the remote controllers to be able to use the sensor facility to better control the temperature as this was a feature that was highlighted to me when making my decision by yourself and also LG comfort cooling. Whilst those problems have been resolved a new problem has been created which could have been resolved with a simple option in the software to remove the differential when the remote sensor is used. Is there anything that can be done as I have a heating system that has very poor control in heating mode.

The weekly timers also cannot be just turned off or deactivated without removing the controller from the wall and pressing the reset button - this occurs on all 4 controllers. They dont appear to be very well designed or fit for purpose.

Kind Regards

eggs
19-03-2013, 12:53 PM
Back 2 Space.

I have followed your threads over the years about your LG problems and a saying keeps going through my mind.

"Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me"

Look at that LG logo, it's winking at you. Don't fall for that cute smile and cheeky wink.

10130 it's saying "You've been had" :) Don't worry your not the only one to be seduced by her..

back2space
20-03-2013, 12:21 AM
Hi Eggs

I know I know I should have learned but when I bought the house I had a perfectly functioning outdoor unit that was a multi system. It was not worth me selling it as I would have got next to nothing back and if it was a 1-1 split I would have just banged it on ebay and got whatever for it but with the multi there was no need to do that.

This is the response from LG - Not really solving the problem more set on trying to tell me that I got the thermo on temp 2c out. Still it doesnt solve the issues I am having with control.


From: ken.macedo@lge.com
To:
Date: Tue, 19 Mar 2013 17:17:11 +0100
Subject: RE: Libero wall mount - Removing the 4C differential in heat mode when using the wired remotes



From:
Sent: 19 March 2013 15:39
To: Ken MACEDO/LGEUK Airconditioning & Energy Solutions(ken.macedo@lge.com)
Subject: Re: Libero wall mount - Removing the 4C differential in heat mode when using the wired remotes



Hi Ken



Thank you for your comments. However this still leaves an issue of 4c over set point which is a concern as why would we want the room temp over shooting 4c at controller height then there's 2c drop before it comes back on.



If I choose 20c you say thermo on will come at 22c but I am wanting To maintain 22c if the room temp reaches 24c while doing so its a high increase isn't it.



Have you got the control strategy for the libero units you could send me please.

https://dub002.mail.live.com/att/GetInline.aspx?messageid=cba7180c-90b0-11e2-a2ce-00237de49cd6&attindex=0&cp=-1&attdepth=0&imgsrc=cid%3aimage002.png%4001CE24BD.35828C50&cid=6cdf8faa26f633f6&hm__login=richard.clarke&hm__domain=live.co.uk&ip=10.111.6.8&d=d4309&mf=0&hm__ts=Wed%2c%2020%20Mar%202013%2000%3a17%3a55%20GMT&st=richard.clarke%25live.co.uk%407&hm__ha=01_c3cc3b3b38b6b14cca87d06669756f159263fa6546d1265f5015940a53724b53&oneredir=1

https://dub002.mail.live.com/att/GetInline.aspx?messageid=cba7180c-90b0-11e2-a2ce-00237de49cd6&attindex=1&cp=-1&attdepth=1&imgsrc=cid%3aimage006.png%4001CE24BD.35828C50&cid=6cdf8faa26f633f6&hm__login=richard.clarke&hm__domain=live.co.uk&ip=10.111.6.8&d=d4309&mf=0&hm__ts=Wed%2c%2020%20Mar%202013%2000%3a17%3a55%20GMT&st=richard.clarke%25live.co.uk%407&hm__ha=01_a4c3f54c20e356be1d36b62f1c47efcf05684d347fc3efadd5bf6f0c14512082&oneredir=1



Also I have tried to cancel the time as per the book and instruction below and it still will not cancel weekly function. Any other timer will cancel as long as its not the weekly function.
I do not know what your issue is, it operates as stated in our “showroom”.



Regards


Sent from my iPhone



From: ken.macedo@lge.com
To: richard.clarke@live.co.uk
Date: Tue, 19 Mar 2013 15:45:22 +0100
Subject: RE: Libero wall mount - Removing the 4C differential in heat mode when using the wired remotes

Hi Richard,

Please see below notes.


Kind Regards,

LGEUK Aircon Helpdesk
Air Conditioning - Technical Support Supervisor
TEL: 0844 847 1402 (Option 4)
Switchboard: 01753 491 500
FAX: 01753 576 525
EMAIL: UK.Aircon@lge.com (UK.Aircon@lge.com)
www.lge.com.uk/aircon (http://www.lge.com.uk/aircon)

https://dub002.mail.live.com/att/GetInline.aspx?messageid=abd48320-90a3-11e2-922b-00237de46104&attindex=1&cp=-1&attdepth=1&imgsrc=cid%3aimage003.jpg%4001CE24B0.6288A750&cid=6cdf8faa26f633f6&hm__login=richard.clarke&hm__domain=live.co.uk&ip=10.111.6.8&d=d4309&mf=0&hm__ts=Wed%2c%2020%20Mar%202013%2000%3a16%3a45%20GMT&st=richard.clarke%25live.co.uk%407&hm__ha=01_74cda48f03322e82c1827647eb77a8d6d0a95b7c78777b15221e153f3cd4d866&oneredir=1

LG Electronics UK Ltd.
Registered Office: LG House, 250 Bath Road, Slough, Berkshire, SL1 4DX / Registered No: 2143888
This e-mail is confidential, legally privileged and intended only for the person to whom it is addressed. If an addressing or transmission error has misdirected this e-mail, please notify the author by replying to this e-mail. If you are not the intended recipient you must not use, disclose, print or rely on this e-mail.
https://dub002.mail.live.com/att/GetInline.aspx?messageid=abd48320-90a3-11e2-922b-00237de46104&attindex=0&cp=-1&attdepth=0&imgsrc=cid%3aimage005.jpg%4001CE24AE.B6AB4470&cid=6cdf8faa26f633f6&hm__login=richard.clarke&hm__domain=live.co.uk&ip=10.111.6.8&d=d4309&mf=0&hm__ts=Wed%2c%2020%20Mar%202013%2000%3a16%3a45%20GMT&st=richard.clarke%25live.co.uk%407&hm__ha=01_a2016228e4e8240e645a0b7e48d70bc822fbd9b3b56b4b00d270595375f1053e&oneredir=1 (http://www.facebook.com/LGUK)│www.lge.com/uk (http://www.lge.com/uk) │www.lgblog.co.uk (http://www.lge.com/uk) │


Email Support - You may also contact the LG technical department by emailing UK.Aircon@lge.com (UK.Aircon@lge.com). This service is available Monday to Friday, between 09:00 and 17:00hrs.






From:
Sent: 19 March 2013 02:17
To: Ken MACEDO/LGEUK Airconditioning & Energy Solutions(ken.macedo@lge.com)
Subject: Libero wall mount - Removing the 4C differential in heat mode when using the wired remotes



Good Morning Ken,

You may remember that I bought wired remotes for my LG wall mounts at home to control the on/off times of the systems rather than using a basic timer plug setup as you said the controller had a temp sensor to better control temperature. All my indoor units are the new style Libero units and work well apart from the fact that in heating there is a 4C differential before set point reaches off. So 22C the return air sensor has to sense 26C before it will cycle off.In Heating Mode, Thermostat OFF = Set-Point + 4 Deg.C; Thermostat ON = Set-Point + 2 Deg.C, therefore it has a 2 Deg.C switching differential.

This in theory would work fine with wall mounts where the return air sensor is at ceiling level. In my house however we was finding that control was very poor as a set point of 22C meant 26C at ceiling level which was usually about 24C at floor level so very warm. The unit would then not reach thermostat on until the temp at ceiling level would then drop below the set point by 1C - this took ages to do as heat rises at ceiling level whilst the occupied area of the room cooled quickly.Incorrect, see above comment.

So part of the desicion to buy the wall wired remotes is that they have sensor in that can be used so room temp is measured at approx light switch level... once this setting was activated on the remote controller I would have thought the 4C differential would not be used so that the differential would be 1C over the set point, this would then work very well. The convertable units have a switch to deactivate high ceiling level (when used at floor level) which basically cancels the differential in heating. With a set point of 22C thermostat off would be reached at 23C. However this isnt how it has worked out, if using the remote control sensor the system still tries to achieve 4C differential so these expensive controllers are nothing more than a glorified timer plug that I could have picked up very cheap! There are various options to use just the unit sensor, the remote sensor or to use an average of them both but in heating all this does is use the lower reading value and not by adding them both together so the lower reading value will always be on the controller.

When I spoke with the helping they said I will have to experiment with the set points but I said well whatever set point I choose for example I could choose 20C the room will still reach 24C before it shuts off(correct) but then the room needs to drop below 20C to 19C(incorrect, Thermostat ON at 22) before thermostat on is reached. This results in large fluctuation in temperatures. The system then wastes a lot of energy running when it doesnt need to. I remember when I spoke with you that you thought there was a setting to remove the differential however there is not.

I have remained very loyal to LG and when I moved into my new house I spent a lot of money on completly new units to remove the problems I was having with the previous units. I then spent near to £400 on the remote controllers to be able to use the sensor facility to better control the temperature as this was a feature that was highlighted to me when making my decision by yourself and also LG comfort cooling. Whilst those problems have been resolved a new problem has been created which could have been resolved with a simple option in the software to remove the differential when the remote sensor is used. Is there anything that can be done as I have a heating system that has very poor control in heating mode.

The weekly timers also cannot be just turned off or deactivated without removing the controller from the wall and pressing the reset button - this occurs on all 4 controllers. They dont appear to be very well designed or fit for purpose.Refer to attached document , and below.

https://dub002.mail.live.com/att/GetInline.aspx?messageid=abd48320-90a3-11e2-922b-00237de46104&attindex=2&cp=-1&attdepth=2&imgsrc=cid%3aimage007.png%4001CE24B0.6288A750&cid=6cdf8faa26f633f6&blob=MXxpbWFnZTAwNy5wbmd8aW1hZ2UvcG5n&hm__login=richard.clarke&hm__domain=live.co.uk&ip=10.111.6.8&d=d4309&mf=0&hm__ts=Wed%2c%2020%20Mar%202013%2000%3a16%3a45%20GMT&st=richard.clarke%25live.co.uk%407&hm__ha=01_24f0faf8135a75af3254c87b4d10d627acb384be0cb467a73eb74c5e0a1fe568&oneredir=1

Kind Regards